Medifast Review

Our Rating:
6.7/10
12 User Reviews

Medifast, Inc. is an American nutrition and weight loss company based in Owings Mills, Maryland.

Shop Now »

Medifast Details

Metric
Value
Our Rating
Calories:
110
9.0/10
Sugar:
7g
7.5/10
Cholesterol:
5mg
9.5/10
Fat:
1g
9.0/10
Carbs:
13g
8.0/10
Dietary Fiber:
4g
7.0/10
Protein:
14g
7.5/10
Organic:
No
4.0/10
Superfoods:
No
4.0/10
Artificial Sweeteners:
Yes
4.0/10
Controversial Ingredients:
Yes
4.0/10
Price Per Serving:
$2.79
7.0/10

Our Medifast Review

WRITTEN BY
Steph Matthiesen - Content Writer

Steph combines her writing and design skills to create unique solutions and content. Rumor has it she subsists solely off caramel lattes and the rhythm of typing. Her website can be found at wordgrower.net. Read More

Medifast 

As far as shake powders go, Medifast’s shake powder is a decent option with several advantages that allow it to compete with top brands. Its formula is particularly apt for diabetics, and it has all the right ingredients to be a good tool for weight loss. However, there are several concerns regarding how the formula might also work against you.

Ingredients

This Medifast shake powder is very low in calories — only 110 per serving, which is very competitive compared to other meal replacement shakes. This makes it a reasonable option for weight loss. In addition to its low calorie content, this Medifast shake earns points in the nutrition department by controlling its macronutrient content. 

This formula contains only 1 gram of fat, but at the same time manages to keep its carb count down to 13 grams. Although this isn’t ideal for a ketogenic diet, it can certainly help with weight control. It also has a very, very low cholesterol content, making it a healthy option for those with elevated cholesterol. Its fiber content is very solid, which means this shake is a great digestion aid and will leave you feeling fuller for longer. In addition, Medifast contains 14 grams of protein, which will also contribute to this feeling of fullness.

Concerns

Despite its advantages, the contents of this Medifast shake powder raise several concerns. Medifast contains no superfoods, and therefore leaves something to be desired in the nutrition department. This shake powder is also not organic, which may or may not be a deal breaker. 

Most troubling are the controversial ingredients this recipe contains. One of the main types of protein in this shake is soy protein. Various studies have linked soy protein to increased levels of estrogen in the body. It has also been correlated with weight gain, which means this shake may end up thwarting your weight loss despite its many advantages.

The sugar content of this shake is relatively low, coming in at 7 grams per serving. But beware: this formula contains artificial sweeteners. Specifically, it contains a high amount of fructose, which has been directly linked to weight gain and obesity. So again, despite its low calorie count and low carb content, this shake may not be your best option for weight loss.

Pricing

Many reviewers have submitted complaints about the pricing of this shake. It appears that the Amazon price of this Medifast powder fluctuates over time. However, its average price of $2.79 per serving is fair. It’s not the most affordable shake, and likely not the best value, but it’s far from being an expensive formula.

Conclusion

This shake is ideal for diabetic people and those looking to reduce their sugar or calorie intake. But while this Medifast shake has all the right characteristics of a good weight loss shake, those seeking to lose weight may want to look elsewhere due to the controversial ingredients in this formula. This is, however, overall a quality shake powder. Its low sugar, carb, fat, and cholesterol contents make it relatively healthy when compared to other shake powders on the market. 

Our Top Meal Replacement Shakes of 2022
#1
2512 User Reviews
9.1/10
Our Rating
2512 User Reviews
9.1/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

310 Shake is a complete superfood meal, providing well-balanced nutrition and targeted ingredients for total immune, digestive, and full-body health. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#2
755 User Reviews
8.9/10
Our Rating
755 User Reviews
8.9/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Garden of Life Raw Meal Shakes are certified organic, vegan and gluten-free. You can find the shake powders at retail stores including Walmart, The Vitamin Shoppe and Whole Foods. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#3
94 User Reviews
8.7/10
Our Rating
94 User Reviews
8.7/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

1UP is focused on shakes and supplements targeted towards gym goers. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#4
134 User Reviews
8.6/10
Our Rating
134 User Reviews
8.6/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Vega sells a variety of plant-based products including shake powders and ready-to-drink shakes, nutritional bars and more.  Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#5
109 User Reviews
8.5/10
Our Rating
109 User Reviews
8.5/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Orgain® is a line of nutritional products including nutrition shakes, protein powder, and protein bars.  Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#6
44 User Reviews
8.5/10
Our Rating
44 User Reviews
8.5/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Teami's strength is making teas, but they have recently started making meal replacement shakes. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#7
179 User Reviews
8.3/10
Our Rating
179 User Reviews
8.3/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Keto chow makes shake mixes specifically for getting into ketosis. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#8
118 User Reviews
8.0/10
Our Rating
118 User Reviews
8.0/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Thrive is a brand from the multi-level marketing company Le-Vel®- producing products such as shakes, flavored drinks, supplements. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#9
247 User Reviews
7.8/10
Our Rating
247 User Reviews
7.8/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

LadyBoss makes supplements for women including "fat burners" "shakes" and "sleep optimizers" Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#10
366 User Reviews
7.8/10
Our Rating
366 User Reviews
7.8/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Shakeology® is a brand from Beachbody LLC, mainly selling shakes at around $129.95 a bag. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#11
98 User Reviews
7.7/10
Our Rating
98 User Reviews
7.7/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Arbonne, a multi-level marketing (MLM) company that sells everything from skincare products to protein powder. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#12
39 User Reviews
7.7/10
Our Rating
39 User Reviews
7.7/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

A low-carb, high quality grass-fed whey protein powder with added MCTs. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#13
1995 User Reviews
7.5/10
Our Rating
1995 User Reviews
7.5/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Ka'Chava provides a high protein shake. They were founded in 2014. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#14
69 User Reviews
7.5/10
Our Rating
69 User Reviews
7.5/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Quest Nutrition, LLC is located in Los Angeles, CA - mainly producing meal replacement shakes and protein bars. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#15
28 User Reviews
7.3/10
Our Rating
28 User Reviews
7.3/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Atkins founded Atkins Nutritionals, Inc. in 1989 to promote the low-carbohydrate products of his increasingly popular Atkins diet. This diet was developed after Atkins read a research paper in the Journal of the American Medical Association. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#16
32 User Reviews
7.2/10
Our Rating
32 User Reviews
7.2/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Glucerna can be used as a snack or meal replacement, and contains CARBSTEADY® -- a blend of slow-release carbohydrates designed to help manage blood sugar levels and reduce spikes. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#17
34 User Reviews
6.9/10
Our Rating
34 User Reviews
6.9/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Available in GNC Stores, Total Lean™ uses a protein blend of Milk Protein Concentrate, Whey Protein Isolates, and Whey Protein Concentrate. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#18
78 User Reviews
6.7/10
Our Rating
78 User Reviews
6.7/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Premier Nutrition manages a collection of CPG brands—each designed to deliver high-quality, great-tasting nutrition that fits into people's lives. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#19
12 User Reviews
6.7/10
Our Rating
12 User Reviews
6.7/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Medifast, Inc. is an American nutrition and weight loss company based in Owings Mills, Maryland.  Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#20
69 User Reviews
6.6/10
Our Rating
69 User Reviews
6.6/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Isagenix is a shake from Isagenix International LLC., a multi-level marketing company. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#21
132 User Reviews
6.3/10
Our Rating
132 User Reviews
6.3/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Herbalife products are sold exclusively through Herbalife Independent Distributors and are NOT available in stores. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#22
55 User Reviews
6.3/10
Our Rating
55 User Reviews
6.3/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Up to 4 hours of hunger control with 10 grams of protein and 4 grams of fiber per serving. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#23
18 User Reviews
5.5/10
Our Rating
18 User Reviews
5.5/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Ensure creates shakes protein shakes for various nutritional needs. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#24
182 User Reviews
4.9/10
Our Rating
182 User Reviews
4.9/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

Huel calls itself a "complete food" with protein, essential fats, fiber, carbohydrates, and all 27 essential vitamins & minerals. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »
#25
13 User Reviews
5.4/10
Our Rating
13 User Reviews
5.4/10
Our Rating
Select Any 2 to Compare

CTRL has sugary themed shakes like "Birthday Cake" and "Cinnamon Toast". They are relatively new to the market. Read Full Review »

Shop Now »