shaker and measuring spoon with meal replacement shake powder on a pink background

Do meal replacement shakes save money? In this article, we’ll look at whether these shakes are a good deal for your pocket. We’ll explore how they can help you lose weight, save money on healthcare, and save time in your busy life. We’ll also compare their costs with buying individual supplements. So, let’s find out if meal replacement shakes are worth it for you, not just in terms of money but also for your health.

Understanding Meal Replacement Shakes

Let’s start by getting the lowdown on meal replacement shakes. These shakes have become quite the trend and for a good reason. They’re designed to replace one or more of your regular meals and come in powder or liquid form. In this analysis, we will dive into the cost-effectiveness of these shakes and what they can mean for you.

The Cost-Effectiveness of Meal Replacement Shakes

financial with stack coin and banknote

Meal replacement shakes pack a punch when it comes to cost-effectiveness. Their benefits go beyond what you see on the price tag. Let’s explore how these shakes can change your life and your wallet.

Accelerating Weight Loss

“Obesity rates have surged globally, with over 650 million obese and 1.9 billion overweight in 2016, primarily affecting women”, WHO. Predictions indicate even higher rates by 2030. Meal replacement shakes, known as weight loss shakes, offer a practical way to combat obesity, accelerating weight loss by reducing calorie intake. Studies show that these shakes can outperform traditional diets.

Beyond weight loss, there are substantial financial benefits. Weight loss can significantly save medication costs, reducing healthcare expenses. “Adult obesity increases medical costs by about $3,508 per person, totaling $315.8 billion nationally”, NIH.

Moreover, losing weight can yield lifetime productivity and direct medical cost savings. A 20-year-old may save over $17,655 from obese to overweight, and even more by reaching a healthy weight. A 40-year-old woman may save $31,447 by achieving a healthy body weight. In conclusion, investing in weight loss with meal replacement shakes improves health and offers significant financial advantages.

Impact on Annual Medical Care Costs

Being at a healthy weight isn’t just about looking good; it’s about staying well. Obesity and its related health issues can lead to some hefty medical bills. But here’s the deal – meal replacement shakes can help you dodge those costs. Making these shakes part of your daily routine may lower the risk of obesity-related conditions like diabetes and heart disease. This, in turn, can translate into significant savings on your yearly medical expenses.

Time-Saving Benefits

White alarm clock on green and blue background

For most women, work is a daily grind. A mother ensures her children are cared for, the house is tidy, and everything is properly placed when she is not pursuing her career. People eat three meals a day on average, and each meal takes between thirty and two hours to prepare.

Remember that time is money; thus, for women carrying a heavy schedule, every minute spent cooking could result in lost income. Shakes that substitute meals are a great way to ensure you eat a balanced diet without spending all day in the kitchen. It takes less than a minute to produce a meal replacement shake. To have a nutritious and well-rounded meal, combine one scoop of the meal replacement shake with some almond milk and shake briefly. This is the exact reason why many women’s are switching to meal replacement shakes now-a-days.

Reducing Supplement Costs

Our modern eating habits often lack the important vitamins and minerals our bodies require in today’s busy world. This leads many of us to take supplements to fill these nutritional gaps.

A study from Australia highlighted this issue, revealing that 13.4% of females, including 10.6% of females above 50 years and 2.8% of women below 50 years, had depleted iron levels. Iron deficiency can lead to irregular heartbeats and, in severe cases, heart murmurs, an enlarged heart, and even heart failure [1].

Another study looked at how common vitamin deficiencies are in seemingly healthy adults. Among the 270 adults in the study, the findings were eye-opening. Vitamin B2 deficiency was the highest at around 50%, followed closely by vitamin B6 at 46%, active B12 at 46%, total B12 at 37%, vitamin B9 (folate) at 32%, vitamin D at 29%, vitamin B1 at 11%, and vitamin A at 6% [2].

These deficiencies come with their own set of problems:

  • Low vitamin B12 can lead to fatigue, confusion, poor memory, and weakness.
  • Not enough vitamin B6 is associated with anemia, confusion, infection susceptibility, depression, and skin problems.
  • A shortage of vitamin B3 can result in vomiting, fatigue, constipation, hallucinations, and even behavioral changes like aggression and suicidal thoughts.
  • A lack of vitamin D causes fatigue, tiredness, a compromised immune system, and bone and back pain.

Many people turn to mineral and vitamin supplements to avoid these troubling symptoms. However, these supplements typically focus on one specific vitamin or mineral. Individuals with multiple deficiencies may spend a lot of money on various supplements.

Product TypePrice RangeDosageDuration
Individual Supplements
Vitamin B12 (Tablets)$5 – $20Typically daily100-200 doses
Multivitamin$10 – $30Typically daily30-90 days
Omega-3 (Fish Oil)$10 – $25Typically daily30-60 days
Vitamin D$5 – $20Typically daily100-120 doses
Calcium$5 – $20Typically daily100-120 doses
Meal Replacement Shakes
HLTH Code Complete Meal$49.95- $99.99 per bag1-2 servings per day15-30 days
310 All-in-One Meal Replacement Shakes$44.99 – $67.49 per bag1-2 servings per day14-28 days
Ready-to-Drink (RTD)$69.95 per bag1 bottle per day15 days

Individual supplements are usually designed to address specific nutritional deficiencies or health concerns. This means that if someone has multiple vitamin deficiencies, they might find themselves taking several different supplements to cover all their needs.

In contrast, meal replacement shakes offer a convenient solution. They’re packed with a variety of essential vitamins and minerals all in one package. This means you can address multiple deficiencies simultaneously, potentially saving money that you might otherwise spend on purchasing separate supplements for each specific condition. Meal replacement shakes can be a cost-effective and efficient way to meet your nutritional requirements comprehensively.

Prevention of Binge Eating

Skipping meals or having unhealthy ones often leads to binge eating later in the day. It’s like a vicious cycle that can lead to consuming more calories and making bad food choices. But meal replacement shakes are here to break that cycle. They provide steady nutrients throughout the day, keeping those impulsive food splurges at bay. The financial benefits of dodging those unplanned food binges can be substantial.

Enhancing Gym Membership Returns

Lots of folks invest in gym memberships to get fit. But here’s the catch – diet plays a massive role in reaching your fitness goals. When you add meal replacement shakes to your routine, you’re giving your body the right nutrition to complement your workouts. That can mean faster progress and possibly fewer expenses on personal trainers or extra fitness programs.


Are Meal Replacement Shakes Pricier Than Regular Meals?

Not necessarily. While the upfront cost of a meal replacement shake might look high compared to cooking your meal, when you factor in the savings on groceries and potential health expenses, the scales can tip in favor of the shakes.

Do Meal Replacement Shakes Cover All Your Nutritional Needs?

Most meal replacement shakes are designed to be a one-stop shop for nutrition, giving you a balanced mix of protein, carbs, and essential vitamins and minerals. However, choosing a trusted brand is vital to ensure you get the nutrients your body needs.

Can You Replace All Your Meals With Shakes Every Day?

While meal replacement shakes are convenient, replacing all your meals with them long-term is not a good idea. A varied diet is essential for your overall health. Shakes work best as occasional meal replacements or as a supplement to a balanced diet.

Are There Any Side Effects From Having Meal Replacement Shakes Regularly?

When used as directed, meal replacement shakes are generally safe. However, it’s smart to consult with a healthcare pro before making significant changes to your diet, especially if you have any underlying health issues.

Do Meal Replacement Shakes Taste Good?

Meal replacement shakes taste can vary from brand to brand and flavor. Some folks find them delightful immediately, while others may need time to get used to them. Experiment with different options to find one that tickles your taste buds.

Final thoughts

In a nutshell, meal replacement shakes offer a cost-effective way to increase your nutrition, manage your weight, and save on healthcare bills. The upfront cost seems steep, but it’s a sweet deal when you tally up the long-term savings, convenience, and health benefits. But remember, meal replacement shakes should be part of a balanced diet, and it’s wise to chat with a healthcare pro before making any major dietary shifts. So, when it comes to meal replacement shakes, it’s not just about the dollars and cents – it’s about the value they bring to your health and overall well-being.


[1] Ahmed, F., Coyne, T., Dobson, A., McClintock, C. (2008). Iron status among Australian adults: findings of a population based study in Queensland, Australia. Asia Pacific journal of clinical nutrition, 17(1).

[2] Kiani, A. K., Dhuli, K., Donato, K., Aquilanti, B., Velluti, V., Matera, G., … Bertelli, M. (2022). Main nutritional deficiencies. Journal of Preventive Medicine and Hygiene, 63(2 Suppl 3), E93.

[wptb id=5842]
Picture of RV Team
RV Team
We’re a team of dedicated and diverse health professionals with proven expertise in the fields of full-body wellness, nutrition, beauty, and fitness. We aim to research and write honest, cutting-edge product reviews and informational articles on relevant health topics that help you make wise, informed buying decisions.

Related Articles

* Reviewology is in partnership or collaborates with top brands highlighted on this site, including those occupying the top ranking positions. 
Additionally, we earn affiliate commissions from products showcased on this website when you make a purchase through the provided links on Amazon or the company website directly.
We appreciate your support using our links to purchase your favorite brands or newly discovered brands.