Meal Replacement Versus Greens- Which is a Better

In our fast-paced world, maintaining a balanced diet can be challenging. Many of us struggle to prepare nutritious meals consistently, leading to gaps in our daily nutritional intake. This has led to the rise of two popular solutions: meal replacement shakes and greens drinks. 

But which one is truly the better choice for overall health?

We’ve analyzed both options to help you understand which might be the better choice for your lifestyle and health goals. We’ll be focusing on several key factors that contribute to overall health and nutrition. 


Meal Replacement Drinks vs. Greens Drinks

We’ll Be Looking At Several Factors:

Convenient Complete Nutrition:
How each option provides balanced macronutrients and micronutrients.
Satiety and Hunger Management:
The ability to curb hunger and reduce unhealthy snacking.
Energy Levels:
How each contributes to sustained energy throughout the day.
Nutrient Profile:
The range of essential vitamins and minerals provided.
Weight Management Support:
How each option can assist with healthy weight goals.
Digestive Health:
Ingredients that promote gut health and digestion.

Key Factors to Consider When Choosing a Nutritional
Support Drink

Nutritional Profile 
Some products focus on providing a full spectrum of nutrients, while others may concentrate on specific areas like plant-based micronutrients.

Protein Content
Consider the amount and quality of protein, which can affect satiety and muscle health.

Ingredient Quality
Look for products that use natural, whole food ingredients rather than artificial additives or fillers.

Taste and Texture
Since you’ll be consuming this regularly, it should be enjoyable. Consider sampling different options to find one you like.

Calorie Content
Ensure the calorie content aligns with your nutritional needs and health goals.

Dietary Compatibility
Check that the product meets any specific dietary requirements you may have (e.g., vegan, gluten-free, non-GMO).

Price and Value
Compare the cost per serving to your usual meal or supplement expenses.

Convenience Factor
Consider how easily the product can be prepared and consumed, especially if you have a busy lifestyle.

Brand Reputation
Research the brand’s history, customer feedback, and transparency in their practices.

Specific Health Benefits
Some products may offer additional benefits like probiotics for gut health or adaptogenic herbs for stress management.

Intended Use
Clarify whether you’re looking for a meal replacement or a supplement to your existing diet.

If the product needs to be mixed, ensure it blends well with your preferred liquid.

By considering these factors, you can make an informed decision about which type of nutritional supplement drink best suits your individual needs and lifestyle.

What to Be Cautious About When Choosing Nutritional
Support Drinks

Sugar Content
Be aware of products with excessive added sugars, which can lead to energy crashes and may interfere with health goals.

Artificial Additives
Some products may contain artificial sweeteners, flavors, or colors. Consider whether you prefer to avoid these.

Nutrient Balance
Check that the product provides a balance of nutrients suitable for your needs. Some may focus more on certain nutrients than others.

Calorie Content
Ensure the calorie count aligns with your nutritional requirements. Some products may be very low in calories, which may or may not suit your goals.

Protein Quality and Quantity
If protein content is important to you, examine the amount and sources used.

Fat Content
Look at the type and amount of fats included. Some products may contain healthier fat profiles than others.

Health Claims
Be cautious of products making exaggerated or unrealistic promises about their benefits.

Micronutrient Profile
Consider whether the product provides a range of vitamins and minerals that complement your diet.

Ingredient Transparency
Be wary of products with long lists of unfamiliar ingredients, which might indicate the presence of fillers or additives.

Quality Assurance
Check if the product has been third-party tested for quality and accuracy of nutritional claims.

Allergies and Sensitivities
Carefully review the ingredient list if you have any food allergies or sensitivities.

Serving Size and Instructions
By keeping these factors in mind, you can make a more informed decision about which nutritional support drink best fits your health needs and preferences.

Here Are Our Top Picks From Each Category
And How They Compare

310 Shakes

Subscription Price Per Serving $2.10


by  AG1

Subscription Price Per Serving $2.63

310 Shakes

by 310 Nutrition

Subscription Price Per Serving $2.10


by AG1

Subscription Price Per Serving $2.63

Convenient Complete Nutrition

310 Nutrition

Comprehensive meal replacement with 15g plant-based protein, 5g fiber, 110 calories

TriPlex Protein Blend for complete amino acid profile

Includes superfoods, vitamins, minerals, probiotics, prebiotics, enzymes, adaptogens

Zero sugar, 6g carbs; suitable for low-carb diets

Various flavors, easy preparation for simplified nutrition


Nutrient-dense supplement: 50 calories, 2g protein, 2g fiber per serving

Focus on micronutrients: probiotics, adaptogens, functional mushrooms, enzymes

Less than 1g sugar per serving
Nutritional boost to complement existing diet

Single flavor option

Some vitamins exceed daily recommended values; monitor intake carefully

Satiety and Hunger Management

310 Nutrition

15g protein and 5g fiber promote fullness

110 calories, yet satisfying like a full meal

Balanced macronutrients stabilize blood sugar

Adjustable thickness for personalized satiety

Effective for weight management


Not designed for hunger management

50 calories, 2g protein; minimal impact on fullness

Supplement, not meal replacement
Focuses on micronutrients, not satiety

May contribute to overall wellness

Requires additional foods for a satisfying meal

Energy Levels

310 Nutrition

Balanced nutrients for sustained energy

15g protein supports steady energy release

Adaptogens may improve energy and reduce fatigue

Vitamins and minerals support cellular energy production

Users report feeling energized without excess calories or sugar


Concentrated micronutrients indirectly support energy

Adaptogens and medicinal mushrooms for balanced energy

Low sugar prevents energy spikes and crashes

May address nutrient deficiencies causing fatigue

50 calories; not a significant caloric energy source

High vitamin content supports energy metabolism

Nutrient Profile

310 Nutrition

15g plant-based protein (TriPlex Protein Blend)

5g fiber, 110 calories, 6g carbs, zero sugar

20 essential vitamins and minerals (20-50% DV)

Superfoods, probiotics, prebiotics, digestive enzymes, adaptogens

Free from artificial additives, dairy, and gluten

Suitable for various diets and weight management


75 ingredients: vitamins, minerals, probiotics, enzymes, adaptogens, mushrooms

High micronutrient levels (some >100% DV)

2g protein, 2g fiber, 50 calories per serving

Various plant-based compounds and extracts

No artificial sweeteners, <1g sugar, dairy-free

Supplement to balanced diet, not meal replacement

Weight Management Support

310 Nutrition

Low-calorie meal replacement (110 calories)

15g protein for satiety and muscle maintenance

5g fiber promotes fullness and digestive health

6g carbs, zero sugar; suitable for low-carb diets

Balanced nutrients support health during calorie deficit

Various flavors help prevent diet fatigue


Not primarily designed for weight management

50 calories; easily fits into calorie-controlled diets

Low protein (2g) and fiber (2g); may not promote satiety

Nutrient-dense; supports overall health during weight loss

Adaptogens may help manage stress-related eating

Single flavor may lead to diet fatigue.

Digestive Health

310 Nutrition

5g fiber supports gut health and regularity

Probiotics and prebiotics for balanced gut flora

Digestive enzymes aid nutrient breakdown and absorption

Plant-based protein blend for easier digestion

Users report improved digestion and reduced bloating

Free from common allergens (dairy, gluten)


Probiotic blend supports gut bacteria balance

Digestive enzymes aid food breakdown and nutrient absorption

2g fiber per serving; may be less effective for fullness/regularity

Plant-based compounds may have anti-inflammatory benefits

Users report improved digestion.

Low sugar, no artificial additives; suitable for sensitive systems

Given the choice between 310 Shakes and AG1, 310 Shakes emerge as the superior option for most consumers seeking to improve their nutrition and maintain a healthy lifestyle.

From a value perspective, 310 Shakes are more cost-effective at $2.10 per serving (with subscription) compared to AG1 at $2.63. This price difference becomes even more significant considering that 310 Shakes can function as a complete meal, while AG1 requires additional food to constitute a full meal.

In conclusion, for those looking to enhance their nutrition with a single, versatile product, 310 Shakes offer a more comprehensive, balanced, and cost-effective solution compared to AG1. While AG1 may have its merits as a supplement, 310 Shakes provide a more practical and satisfying option for everyday nutrition and meal replacement needs.

Our Top Choice

Picture of RV Team
RV Team
We’re a team of dedicated and diverse health professionals with proven expertise in the fields of full-body wellness, nutrition, beauty, and fitness. We aim to research and write honest, cutting-edge product reviews and informational articles on relevant health topics that help you make wise, informed buying decisions.

Related Articles

* Reviewology is in partnership or collaborates with top brands highlighted on this site, including those occupying the top ranking positions. 
Additionally, we earn affiliate commissions from products showcased on this website when you make a purchase through the provided links on Amazon or the company website directly.
We appreciate your support using our links to purchase your favorite brands or newly discovered brands.