During our search for convenient meal replacement shakes that align with our low-carb diet, we’ve come across two well-known options: 310 Shakes and Shakeology. Both have distinct features and a set of strong product offerings for health improvement.
Therefore, we’ve used a few of their flavors to test out the brands’ potential performance. Which drink might be the better option for a majority of people? Let’s find out in our comparison of these two reputable brands from different perspectives while also estimating their value.
- Calories
- Net Carbs
- Sugar
- Protein
- Dietary Fiber
- Cholesterol
- Artificial Sweetener
- Superfoods
- Controversial Ingredients
- Calories
- Net Carbs
- Sugar
- Protein
- Total Fat
- Dietary Fiber
- Artificial Sweetener
- Superfoods
- Controversial Ingredients
310 Shakes: A Quick Overview
Shakeology: A Deep Insight
310 Shakes vs Shakeology Nutritional Comparison
Let’s take a closer look at the detailed nutritional breakdown of 310 Shakes vs. Shakeology to help determine which drink aligns best with a healthy diet:
| 310 Nutrition | Shakeology | |
|---|---|---|
Protein Content |
310 Shakes offer 15-20g of plant-based protein (pea, brown rice, pumpkin) per serving |
Shakeology offers around 15g of protein per serving from a blend of plant-based sources like pea, chia seed, and quinoa. |
Calories and Macronutrients |
310 Shakes generally contain around 90 to 110 calories per serving. The shakes also have zero sugar and less cholesterol.
|
Shakeology varies slightly in its calorie content depending on the flavor, but it generally provides around 160 to 170 calories per serving. The shake may contain almost three times higher carbohydrate content when compared to 310 Shakes. |
Fiber |
310 Shakes are known for their high fiber content, often providing around 5 to 7 grams of dietary fiber per serving. This can help promote a feeling of fullness and support digestive health. |
Shakeology typically contains 4-6 grams of fiber per serving, which is a bit less than 310 Shakes, although it will still contribute to satiety. |
Micronutrient Profile |
310 Shakes focuses on the superfoods, vitamins, and minerals in its formula to create a well-balanced nutritional profile. ​ |
Shakeology also focuses on delivering a wide range of nutrients, including vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, prebiotics, probiotics, and phytonutrients. |
Flavors and Variety |
310 Shakes have 11 different flavors. Basic flavors like chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry are available. In addition, the brand also has mocha, chocolate icing, gingerbread, peppermint, and many other unique flavors. |
Shakeology doesn’t have as many unique flavors as 310 Shakes. Instead, it has basic flavors like chocolate, vanilla, and latte. Other flavors are just a mixture of these basic flavors |
Price |
Generally, 310 Shakes are considered more affordable than Shakeology, making them an attractive option for budget conscious consumers. |
Shakeology is a bit costly when compared to 310 Shakes. But, the cost comparison ultimately depends on consumer needs and demands. |
Pros and Cons: 310 Shakes vs Shakeology
When comparing 310 Shakes and Shakeology, it’s essential to consider and understand their pros and cons. Both of these meal replacement beverages offer unique features and nutritional values.Â
So in some way, they can ultimately both match different users’ preferences and dietary needs. Let’s dive into the strengths and weaknesses of 310 Shakes and Shakeology to find out which one best suits consumers’ nutritional needs.
Pros and Cons: 310 Shakes vs Shakeology
When comparing 310 Shakes and Shakeology, it’s essential to consider and understand their pros and cons. Both of these meal replacement beverages offer unique features and nutritional values.Â
So in some way, they can ultimately both match different users’ preferences and dietary needs. Let’s dive into the strengths and weaknesses of 310 Shakes and Shakeology to find out which one best suits consumers’ nutritional needs.
Analyzing 310 Shakes vs Shakeology: Pros and Cons
310 Shakes: Pros
- Affordable Option:
- 310 Shakes are known for their budget-friendly pricing, making them accessible to a wide range of consumers.
- Low in Calories and Carbs:
- These shakes offer a lower calorie and lower carb option, suitable for those aiming to manage their calorie intake.
- High in Dietary Fiber:
- With its high fiber content, 310 Shakes help promote a feeling of fullness while supporting digestive health.
- Variety of Available Flavors:
- 310 Shakes provide a range of delicious flavors, allowing users to choose their favorite taste profiles.
- Plant-Based Protein Sources:
- The shakes emphasize plant-based proteins, making them suitable for vegans and those seeking plant-based options.
310 Shakes: Cons
- Available Online Only
- Sometimes On Backorder Due To High Demand
Shakeology: Pros
- Comprehensive Nutrition:
- Shakeology offers a comprehensive blend of nutrients, including vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, and superfoods.
- Support for Holistic Health:
- Shakeology includes various superfoods like chia seeds and quinoa, which enhance its nutritional profile.
- Variety of Available Flavors:
- The shake comes in a range of delicious flavors, allowing users to find one that best suits their taste preferences.
Shakeology: Cons
- Higher Price Point:
- Shakeology is generally more expensive than other meal replacement options on the market.
- Slightly Higher in Calories:
- The shake typically contains more calories when compared to some lower calorie meal replacement shakes.
- Flavor Preferences Vary:
- Taste is subjective, and some individuals may not find all Shakeology flavors to their liking.
Which to Choose: 310 Shakes or Shakeology
Having had the chance to put both Shakeology and 310 Nutrition Shakes to the test during our journey, we can honestly say the experiences were like night and day.
Let's kick things off with 310 Shakes
This immediately piqued our interest with their impressive nutritional lineup. These drinks offer a fantastic nutritional balance with their high protein content, low calories, and inclusion of superfoods. What really caught our eye was their sugar-free, dairy-free, and gluten-free alternatives. Â
And the best part? There weren’t any artificial ingredients being snuck into the mixture. In our personal journey, 310 Shakes have proven to be a delicious, practical, and downright effective addition to our daily health regimen.Â
Taste-wise, it knocked it out of the park. We loved the creamy, rich flavor, and the fact that the drinks were not overly sweet. In addition, the Chocolate Bliss flavor had that deep cocoa hit, while the Vanilla Creme flavor was like a dessert in a glass.Â
The fact that the brand uses natural sweeteners to strike that perfect balance made us appreciate them even more. Plus, it’s blended like a dream and went down silky smooth.
Now, let's shift gears to Shakeology
Our initial excitement was met with a bit of a curveball. Despite all the nutritional goodness packed, the Chocolate Whey Shake had a peculiar, strong flavor that didn’t quite hit the mark for our taste buds.Â
We tried playing around with recipes, adding various ingredients, even giving almond milk and spices a whirl, but that unique taste just wouldn’t budge. On the flip side, we couldn’t deny the boost in energy and that satisfying fullness we felt after drinking it. When we put the two side by side, 310 Shakes came out as our clear favorite.Â
Not only did it offer a lip-smacking flavor, but it also had a holistic nutritional profile, and the flexibility to cater to various dietary needs. Shakeology, while undoubtedly a nutritional powerhouse, faced a bit of an uphill battle with the taste. However, it might not be the best for those who are worried about distinct health issues.Â
As we mentioned before, Shakeology has higher cholesterol and carbs, which might not be a good option for low carb diet users because high cholesterol may lead to several health difficulties. Overall, we preferred 310 Shakes as low-carb diet eaters. If someone doesn’t follow a strict diet, we feel that Shakeology would be a good option.
Final Thoughts
From our perspective, we were pretty fascinated by both 310 Shakes and Shakeology. So, we couldn’t help but try both and draw a meaningful comparison between the two. While some might think there is a real winner here, we wouldn’t quite describe it like that.Â
While 310 Shakes balance out their nutritional output, Shakeology focuses on more of a caloric output with its high carb and cholesterol content. As low-carb diet followers, we would prefer 310 Shakes in the 310 Shakes vs Shakeology debate.Â
Similarly, this might also be true for many people who are concerned with carb and cholesterol related issues. On the other hand, if someone doesn’t have those conditions and is free to consume high carbs, Shakeology would be a potential solid option for them.
Our Top Choice
References
- Abete, I., Parra, M., Zulet, M., & MartÃnez, J. (2006). Different dietary strategies for weight loss in obesity: Role of energy and macronutrient content. Nutrition Research Reviews, 19(1), 5-17. https://doi.org/10.1079/NRR2006112
- Tacer-Caba, Z. (2019). The concept of superfoods in diet. In The role of alternative and innovative food ingredients and products in consumer wellness (pp. 73-101). Academic Press. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-816453-2.00003-6
- Kris Gunnars, BSc and Rachael Ajmera, MS, RD.(December 13, 2023). A Low Carb Meal Plan and Menu to Improve Your Health. (para.1-2). https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/low-carb-diet-meal-plan-and-menu
Gina Wangrycht is a seasoned freelance editor/proofreader and writer with 21 years of experience working in the communication field for a variety of different industries, including healthcare, insurance, education, retail technology, and non-profit.
Gina Wangrycht is a seasoned freelance editor/proofreader and writer with 21 years of experience working in the communication field for a variety of different industries, including healthcare, insurance, education, retail technology, and non-profit.
Previous Article